Unable to generate App Store Connect API Key

I am using expo-dev-client. I have been trying to change the Apple Developer Account of my app (that was just in Testflight).

What I did was, create a new Apple Developer Account with a new bundle identifier, and tried to build + submit the app. It worked fine but I have been unable to generate an ASC API Key.

I run eas credentials and then then Set up your project to use an API Key for EAS Submit and this is the error I get:

:heavy_check_mark: What do you want to do? › Set up your project to use an API Key for EAS Submit
:heavy_check_mark: Generate a new App Store Connect API Key? … yes
:heavy_multiplication_x: Failed to create App Store Connect API Key.
UnexpectedAppleResponse: The specified resource does not exist - There is no resource of type ‘apiKeys’ with id ‘K5PR28RM5W’
Cryptic error? Learn more: fyi/cryptic-error-eas.md at main · expo/fyi · GitHub
Press any key to continue…

eas-cli/0.56.0 darwin-arm64 node-v14.19.3